It’s (Indeed) A Tie Candidates Agree: Runoff, Not Coin Toss COOPERSTOWN – The Otsego County Board of Elections today certified the Republican Mary Margaret Robbins and Democrat MacGuire Benton are indeed tied at 272 votes for a Cooperstown Village Board seat. The next question: coin toss or runoff? Both candidate ruled out the coin-toss option. “I want the people to decide,” Benton said. “The vote is critically important; it’s democracy.” Asked if she supported a runoff election, Robbins replied, “Absolutely. …